The Science of BBQ - The BBQ Stall
The first time I attempted smoking food, it turned into a debacle. I struggled to regulate the heat inside the BBQ and was clueless about handling temperature stalls in the meat. Picture me, frantically adjusting the vents on my smoker, adding charcoal, all while my family impatiently waited at the dinner table.
If you're a regular charcoal BBQ or smoker user, you're likely familiar with this frustrating occurrence— the BBQ stall. Also referred to as the plateau or the zone. But what exactly is the BBQ stall? What triggers it? And most importantly, how can you navigate past or prevent it? Discover the answers to these questions in this article.
What is the BBQ Stall?
The stall, the plateau, or the zone occurs when smoking or cooking larger cuts of meat at low temperatures for extended periods of time. It is when the interior temperature of that meat reaches about 150°F to 170°F (66°C to 77°C) and stops going up. This state can last for hours.
A friend and smoking enthusiast, Stew (@s2bbq) has worked smoking down to a science, however, even he admits things don’t always go as planned. A pulled pork dinner with friends, which he had done several times before, once took three and a half hours longer than expected. Even after wrapping the pork at 160°, he had a huge stall. Stew eventually resorted to cranking the heat, something he doesn’t like to do. Needless to say, dinner for 6-ish was at 9:30, and the pork did not get rested at all. It was still delicious though.
What Causes the BBQ Stall?
The stall is caused by the evaporation of liquid on the meat's surface. This evaporative cooling works just like when you sweat while working hard. The stall can get frustrating because it lasts for hours. It is because the heating rate of the meat and the temperature of the smoker matches that of the rate of evaporative cooling.
Does that mean that your meat will lose all of its moisture and turn into a dry hunk of yuck? No. First of all, the meat won't remain in the stall forever. There is a finite amount of excess moisture available to be consumed when meat is in this state. The rest of the moisture in the meat is tied up in the collagen, fat, and protein where it will remain to create that succulent meat jello that we love. Once that excess moisture is used up, your meat should start raising in temperature once more.
Factors that Affect the Stall
There are many factors that can and do affect the stall, whether it's for the better or worse. Airflow and humidity are the two biggest.
The weather can sometimes have a huge impact on your smoke. Stew had planned to do an overnight smoke on a 10 lb (4.5 kg) brisket. The day was slightly overcast, not too hot or cold or humid, and there was no wind. There was also no stall whatsoever. The brisket, which should have been ready at 4 am, was done before they went to bed! It was well wrapped, rested in a cooler until morning, and, when served, pretty darn good. Weather, the density of the charcoal being used, the density of the meat, airflow, and moisture can all make a difference in the way your smoke goes.
Airflow
This is most noticeable in wood and bullet-style smokers where there are multiple parts, ports, and such like. This doesn't make these units less effective at smoking an award-winning brisket, it is just a factor that you need to be aware of when using them.
Moisture
Moisture is a funny thing. There is moisture coming from the meat, additional moisture from the day's humidity, additional moisture from a baste, mop, or spray, and additional moisture when you use a water pan. Adding moisture is a double-edged blade when it comes to smoking. Further, you are likely to see a shorter stall on a dry day as opposed to one that is quite humid.
Using a water pan is a good idea when you are smoking anything. The liquid will evaporate raising the humidity within the unit you are using. This slows the evaporation process on the surface of the meat allowing the interior temperature of the meat to catch up with the temperature on the outside of the meat promoting uniform cooking. The liquid from water pan also condenses on the meat and the smoke will stick to it, increasing the delightful smoky flavour that you are after.
Basting, mopping, spraying, and using a water pan do make an impact on your cooking time by lengthening it. Cool liquid and/or liquid vapor are landing on the surface of the meat and cooling it as the liquid evaporates - the conditions that create the stall in the first place. That doesn't mean that you don't want to use any of these methods when smoking. You should use at least one of these when smoking to ensure that there is enough moisture available to the meat to keep smoker temperatures at a good smoking level for flavour transference and to keep the process slow enough for the collagen and fat to render properly.
How to Get Past or Avoid the Stall
That's a Wrap
You can wrap your meat in foil to avoid or get past the stall. This technique is known as the Texas Crutch. By adding some liquid - juice, wine, beer, watered sauce - and tightly wrapping your meat in foil, you create an environment of nearly one hundred percent humidity, effectively braising the meat during the second half of your smoke. When you take this course of action to avoid or get past the stall, remember to finish cooking your meat to its finished temperature - as per the recipe - before unwrapping as evaporative cooling will cool the meat quickly when you unwrap.
Many purists of smoking are likely falling to their knees screaming "Won't someone think about the bark?!" And they do have a point. If you like your bark crisp and hard, the Texas Crutch may not be your ideal solution. Some will use butcher paper instead, stating that it is a great "in-between" solution, just remember to get unwaxed paper because the coating will melt. You can also re-solidify bark by hitting it with a little dry and high heat before slicing.
Turn it Up
If the prospect of soggy paper gives you the heebs as it does for me, then you can opt for raising the temperature of your BBQ to try and get past the stall. As mentioned earlier, evaporative cooling is causing the meat to remain at a steady temperature. Increasing your cook temperature will not prevent the stall but can shorten the time that it will take. The principal thought is to use heat energy to overpower the evaporative cooling temperature. This is because at lower temperatures they tend to balance each other out. The downside to this technique is the danger that the heat will disrupt the rendering of fat and connective tissue and cause the meat to become tough. Increasing your smoker's temperature from 225°F (107°C) to around 325°F (163°C) until the meat is done will also ensure a better bark and can be effective on pork shoulders, however, results are not so great with brisket.
Specifically, for briskets, you can separate the point and the flat before smoking. Rub them both thoroughly and smoke them at the same time while monitoring both of their temperatures individually. That way you can decide if you need to wrap the flat or not. The benefit being that the point will develop a deep bark and smoke ring, which are ideal for burnt ends.
Just Don't Look
Finally, you can set your smoker up for the long haul with a water pan and just let it go. Many people use the no-peek technique and will plan the smoke with the stall (and even a second stall - which can happen) in mind. Set your smoker up, only opening things to add more water to the pan, or more charcoal and wood to the basket as needed. Using a wireless digital thermometer like Napoleon's Wireless Bluetooth Digital BBQ Thermometer will allow you to monitor both the BBQ and the meat's temperature.
People Also Asked:
What is the Stall in BBQ?
The stall in BBQ, also known as the "BBQ stall," is a phenomenon where the internal temperature of the meat plateaus or stops rising during the cooking process, despite continued application of heat. This stall typically occurs when the meat reaches a certain temperature range, causing moisture evaporation and cooling effects that counteract the heat from the smoker.
What is the Stall at 170°F For a Brisket?
The stall at 170°F (77°C) for a brisket refers to the temperature at which brisket may experience a plateau during the smoking process. At this point, the meat may seem to stop cooking and can remain at this temperature for an extended period, which can be frustrating for barbecue enthusiasts.
How Long Does the Stall Last?
The duration of the stall in BBQ can vary depending on several factors, including the size and thickness of the meat, the cooking temperature, and the humidity level. Generally, the stall can last anywhere from one to several hours. It's essential to monitor the temperature carefully and be patient as the meat slowly progresses through the stall. The easiest way to monitor your cook is to use a digital thermometer that you can leave in the meat. Try the Napoleon Wireless Digital Thermometer.
How do you Beat the Stall When Smoking a Pork Shoulder?
To beat the stall when smoking a pork shoulder, there are several techniques you can try. One method is to wrap the pork shoulder tightly in aluminum foil or butcher paper once it enters the stall phase. This technique, known as the "Texas Crutch," helps accelerate the cooking process by trapping moisture and heat, ultimately reducing the time spent in the stall. Additionally, some pitmasters choose to increase the cooking temperature slightly or spritz the meat with a liquid, such as apple juice or cider vinegar, to help break through the stall and promote more even cooking. Ultimately, patience and careful monitoring of the meat's temperature are key to successfully overcoming the stall when smoking a pork shoulder.
Tell us how you manage the stall when you smoke by using the hashtags #TheSmokeStall and #NapoleonGrills and tagging us in photos and comments on our social pages like Facebook and Instagram.
Happy Grilling!